Jason,

You are right. I find that I play worse against bad players because I assume they are bad, which is very very -ev. In this case I called, but I agree that all evidence point to fold. I have started getting better at folding good hands on flop, ie, I find that my life is much better (more +ev), when I fold to most decent reraises on the flop even with top pair type of hands, do i miss some value? I know i do. But the more I play the more I realize that it is okay the fold the best on the flop. That's a hard concept for me to accept.

!luck