Yeah we are mixing up our arguments here. So let me clarify.
12% is feasible given the fact his overall pfr% is 12%. That bit was just disagreeing with MMM.
I agree it's unlikely because I doubt this nit would do it.
The wide range I said I might iso with was to illustrate that an iso range can be as wide or wider than the overall pfr %.
The first range I gave of 9% or w/e was just to be more agreeable with general consensus. The 7% or w/e is what I actually think is most likely.